Mothers, Daughters, and Body Image: Learning to Love Ourselves as We Are

Hillary McBride was a graduate student, still in recovery from an eating disorder, when she started the research that turned into this book. It shows in both directions. There’s a rawness to the writing that you don’t get from someone studying a problem they’ve only read about. There are also the structural problems of a first book written by someone who was learning how to write one at the same time.

The Editing Is the Least of It

The prose is choppy. Sentences run long, commas turn up where periods belong, and the same idea comes back around three or four times in different chapters. Readers have been saying this since it came out and they’re right. Post Hill Press did McBride no favors.

The bigger problem is who’s in the book. McBride interviewed women and their mothers about their bodies, and those interviews are the whole engine of the thing. As far as you can tell from the text, all of those women were white. Race gets a nod and then the book moves on. Class barely gets that much; the voices skew comfortable. And there’s no fat-positive perspective anywhere in a book about learning to accept your body, which was a strange gap in 2017 and is a stranger one now.

So if what you need is a book that understands body image as something that happens at the intersection of race, size, and money, this isn’t the one. The Body Is Not an Apology does that work, and does it well.

So Why Read It Anyway

Almost all body image research studies what goes wrong. You recruit people with disordered eating, measure the disorder, test an intervention against it. McBride went the other way. She found women who had a decent relationship with their own bodies and asked them how that happened.

Comparison: how most body image research works versus the question Hillary McBride asked in Mothers, Daughters, and Body Image

Different question, different answers. What you get isn’t a list of risk factors. It’s closer to a description of what protection actually looks like from the inside: what these women’s mothers said, what they pointedly didn’t say, what happened at puberty, and where any of it came from when it didn’t come from home.

If you’ve read a stack of eating disorder books and come away with a sharp picture of how things break and a fuzzy one of how they hold, this is the corrective.

The Ladder

McBride’s central image is a ladder. Your mother climbs partway up and gives you a start higher than the one she got. Then sometimes, and this is the part people remember, you reach back down and pull her up a rung.

The ladder: how body image gets handed down between mothers and daughters, and how repair travels back up

It’s a good metaphor because it refuses both of the easy stories. It isn’t “your mother did this to you.” It isn’t “she did her best, let it go.” It’s an account of how a body story gets handed down that runs in both directions and leaves the repair available in the present tense, not just in hindsight.

Anyone who has sat across from their mother and heard her say the exact thing about her own body that they say about theirs will recognize it immediately. This is also the material that surfaces constantly in family therapy, usually without anyone having planned to bring it up.

If you read one part of this book, read that one.

The Spirituality Chapter

There’s a chapter on spirituality, and it’s the one readers react to hardest in both directions.

The chapter treats spiritual practice as part of how some of these women arrived at peace with their bodies. Whether that reads as generous or as an assumption you never agreed to depends almost entirely on what you’re bringing to it. Plenty of readers found it presumptive. Others name it as the chapter that got them.

If religious framing about bodies is something you’ve had to recover from rather than something you reach for, you’ll know within a page. Skip it. Nothing after it depends on it.

Worth flagging separately: the book occasionally drifts into language about food and health that sits badly next to its own argument. Not constantly. But enough that if you’re in eating disorder recovery, go in knowing it’s in there.

Mothers, Daughters, and Everyone Else

The title is accurate, which is also the limit.

This is a book about cis women and their cis mothers, arguing about “womanhood” as though it’s one shared thing. Trans and nonbinary embodiment doesn’t come up at all. Neither does the more common queer situation, where the person who taught you how to live in a body wasn’t your mother in the first place, and whatever repair happened, happened somewhere in chosen family.

That’s not a reason to skip the book. The mechanism McBride describes travels fine: a story about your body gets handed to you before you’re old enough to evaluate it, and then you either repeat it or interrupt it. You’ll just be doing the translation yourself, and the book won’t help you with it. If the gendered part is the hard part, if the trouble is the body you were assigned rather than the body you were taught to criticize, that’s separate work and this book isn’t built for it. Trans affirming therapy is a better place to start.

Where to Start and What to Skip

Go to the interview chapters and the ladder material first. That’s the real contribution: actual women describing, with enough specificity to be useful, how they got somewhere reasonable with their bodies.

The media literacy chapter is thin. You can guess what it says.

The reflection questions at the end of each chapter are better than they look, though only if you actually write the answers down, which nearly nobody does. And if you’re working somatically, the material on being in your body pairs well with what happens in somatic therapy, because it gives language to things that are otherwise hard to say out loud.

One more thing. If McBride’s thinking interests you more than this particular book does, The Wisdom of Your Body from 2021 is the better book by a wide margin. The writing is cleaner and she had four more years of clinical practice behind her by the time she wrote it. If you’re only going to read one McBride book, read that one.

If what stuck with you was the inheritance part, the sense of carrying something that started before you did, It Didn’t Start with You goes at that directly, and reaches back further than one generation.

  • Hillary L. McBride